Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars: Ultimate Candy Bar Dessert

Introduction

Picture the ultimate dessert that combines America’s favorite candy bars with creamy cheesecake perfection. Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars deliver exactly that incredible combination! Additionally, these bars transform beloved candy flavors into an elegant dessert that’s perfect for sharing. Moreover, every bite offers the perfect balance of peanut butter, chocolate, and toffee crunch that makes these treats absolutely irresistible.

These decadent bars feature a buttery graham cracker crust topped with rich cream cheese filling loaded with crushed Butterfinger pieces and chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Furthermore, the bar format makes them perfect for parties, potlucks, or any time you want impressive desserts without individual plating. Therefore, whether you’re feeding a crowd or just treating your family, these bars always disappear quickly.

Why You’ll Love Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

These incredible dessert bars offer everything you could want in a sweet treat. Additionally, they solve the common problem of choosing between different candy bar flavors by including both favorites.

Here’s why Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars are absolutely amazing:

• Two candy bar flavors in one: Combines the best of peanut butter cups and toffee crunch candy • Easy bar format: No need for individual serving or complicated plating techniques • Make-ahead convenience: Actually improves in flavor when chilled overnight before serving • Crowd-pleasing size: 9×13 pan yields plenty of servings for parties and gatherings • Impressive presentation: Looks professionally made despite simple preparation techniques • Perfect texture contrast: Creamy cheesecake filling contrasts beautifully with crunchy candy pieces • Customizable sweetness: Adjust candy amounts to suit different preference levels

Moreover, these bars transport easily and hold their shape well for potlucks and events. Furthermore, the combination of familiar candy flavors makes them appealing to both kids and adults.

Essential Ingredients for Perfect Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

Creating exceptional Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars requires quality ingredients in proper proportions. Additionally, understanding each component’s role ensures consistent, delicious results every time.

Graham Cracker Crust Foundation

Building the perfect base: • 2 cups graham cracker crumbs: Creates the classic cheesecake foundation with subtle honey sweetness • 1/2 cup melted butter: Binds crumbs together and adds rich, buttery flavor

Furthermore, using finely ground crumbs creates a more cohesive crust than coarse pieces. Therefore, process whole graham crackers in a food processor for best texture and binding.

Creamy Cheesecake Filling

The heart of these decadent bars: • 3 (8 oz) packages cream cheese, softened: Forms the luxurious, smooth base texture • 1 cup granulated sugar: Provides sweetness that balances the rich candy flavors • 3 large eggs: Creates structure and contributes to the creamy, set texture • 1 tsp vanilla extract: Enhances all other flavors and adds aromatic depth

Additionally, room temperature ingredients blend much more easily and prevent lumps. Moreover, softened cream cheese should give slightly when pressed but not be completely warm.

Signature Candy Bar Mix-Ins

The stars that make these bars special: • 1 cup crushed Butterfinger candy bars: Adds distinctive toffee crunch and buttery caramel notes • 1 cup chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups: Contributes rich peanut butter and chocolate flavors

Furthermore, crushing candy bars to uniform sizes ensures even distribution throughout the filling. Therefore, aim for pieces that are roughly 1/4 to 1/2 inch in size for optimal texture.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

Creating these incredible bars involves straightforward steps that build layers of flavor and texture. Additionally, following proper techniques ensures professional-quality results at home.

Step 1: Preparing Your Pan and Crust

Proper preparation prevents sticking and makes removal much easier. Furthermore, the right crust technique creates the perfect foundation for your bars.

Set up for success:

1. Preheat oven to 325°F (160°C): Moderate temperature ensures even baking without burning
2. Line 9×13-inch pan with parchment: Leave overhang for easy removal after chilling
3. Mix crust ingredients: Combine graham cracker crumbs with melted butter until evenly moistened
4. Press firmly into pan: Use flat-bottomed measuring cup to create even, compact layer
5. Pre-bake for 8 minutes: Sets the crust and prevents soggy bottom

Additionally, spraying parchment paper lightly with cooking spray prevents sticking. Moreover, ensuring even crust thickness prevents thick and thin spots that affect cutting.

Step 2: Creating the Perfect Cheesecake Filling

The filling requires careful attention to mixing order and technique. Furthermore, proper preparation ensures smooth, lump-free texture throughout.

Master the cheesecake base:

1. Beat cream cheese until fluffy: Takes 3-4 minutes and eliminates any lumps completely
2. Gradually add sugar: Scrape bowl sides frequently for even incorporation
3. Add vanilla extract: Mix thoroughly to distribute flavor evenly
4. Incorporate eggs one at a time: Beat just until blended to prevent overmixing
5. Check for smoothness: Mixture should be completely smooth without any streaks

Moreover, overmixing after adding eggs incorporates too much air, causing cracks. Therefore, mix on low speed and stop as soon as ingredients combine completely.

Step 3: Adding the Candy Bar Magic

Incorporating candy pieces requires gentle folding to prevent breaking. Additionally, proper distribution ensures every bite contains both candy flavors.

Fold in candy perfectly:

1. Prepare candy pieces: Ensure Butterfinger and Reese’s pieces are uniformly sized
2. Fold gently: Use rubber spatula to incorporate without crushing candy further
3. Distribute evenly: Scrape bottom and sides to ensure even candy distribution
4. Check coverage: Every spoonful should contain both types of candy pieces
5. Pour over crust: Spread evenly without disturbing the pre-baked crust layer

Furthermore, chilling candy bars before chopping makes them easier to cut cleanly. Therefore, refrigerate candy for 30 minutes before crushing for best results.

Step 4: Baking and Cooling Your Cheesecake Bars

Proper baking and cooling techniques prevent common problems like cracking and sinking. Additionally, patience during cooling ensures perfect texture and easy cutting.

Achieve perfect baking results:

1. Bake for 35-40 minutes: Center should be set but still slightly jiggly
2. Check doneness: Edges should be set and lightly golden
3. Cool gradually: Turn off oven and crack door open for gradual cooling
4. Room temperature cooling: Allow to cool completely before refrigerating
5. Chill at least 4 hours: Proper chilling firms texture for clean cutting
6. Cut with clean knife: Wipe blade between cuts for professional appearance

Moreover, a toothpick inserted near center should come out with just a few moist crumbs. Furthermore, overbaking creates dense, dry texture rather than creamy cheesecake consistency.

Pro Tips for the Best Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

These expert techniques help you achieve bakery-quality results consistently. Additionally, small details make significant differences in the final product quality.

Candy Preparation Secrets

Proper candy preparation affects both texture and flavor distribution. Furthermore, these techniques ensure optimal candy integration throughout the bars.

Master candy preparation:

• Freeze before crushing: Frozen candy bars break more cleanly without sticky mess • Use proper tools: Food processor pulses work better than crushing by hand • Consistent sizing: Uniform pieces distribute more evenly and look more professional • Reserve some for topping: Sprinkle extra pieces on top before baking for visual appeal

Additionally, different candy bars require different crushing techniques. Moreover, Butterfinger breaks more easily than Reese’s, so process them separately.

Temperature Control Mastery

Temperature management affects every aspect of cheesecake bar success. Furthermore, understanding proper temperatures prevents common problems before they occur.

Perfect temperature techniques:

• Room temperature ingredients: Cream cheese and eggs blend smoothly when properly warmed • Proper baking temperature: 325°F prevents burning while ensuring thorough cooking • Gradual cooling: Sudden temperature changes cause cracking and texture issues • Adequate chilling: Minimum 4 hours allows proper setting and flavor development

Moreover, using an oven thermometer ensures accurate temperature control. Therefore, invest in a reliable thermometer if your oven runs hot or cold.

Creative Variations of Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

Transform this basic recipe into exciting new flavor combinations with simple modifications. Additionally, seasonal variations keep these bars interesting throughout the year.

Triple Chocolate Butterfinger Bars

Create an ultra-chocolatey version for serious chocolate lovers. Furthermore, these modifications intensify the chocolate experience while maintaining the signature candy flavors.

Enhance chocolate elements:

• Chocolate graham crust: Use chocolate graham crackers instead of regular ones • Add cocoa powder: Include 1/4 cup unsweetened cocoa in the filling • Chocolate chips: Fold in 1/2 cup mini chocolate chips with the candy pieces • Chocolate drizzle: Top cooled bars with melted chocolate for elegant finish

Additionally, using dark chocolate intensifies the flavor without adding excessive sweetness. Therefore, consider dark chocolate chips and drizzle for sophisticated taste.

Peanut Butter Lovers’ Cheesecake Bars

Amplify the peanut butter flavor for true peanut butter enthusiasts. Moreover, these modifications create the ultimate peanut butter dessert experience.

Boost peanut butter intensity:

• Peanut butter in filling: Add 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter to the cream cheese mixture • Peanut butter crust: Mix 2 tablespoons peanut butter into the crust mixture • Extra Reese’s pieces: Increase Reese’s to 1.5 cups for more peanut butter flavor • Chopped peanuts: Add 1/2 cup chopped roasted peanuts for extra crunch

Furthermore, natural peanut butter works better than processed varieties in baking. Therefore, choose brands without added oils or excessive sugar for best results.

Seasonal Holiday Variations

Adapt these bars for different holidays and celebrations throughout the year. Additionally, themed variations make them perfect for special occasions.

Create holiday magic:

• Halloween version: Use Halloween-themed Reese’s and orange-colored elements • Christmas bars: Add crushed candy canes and red/green sprinkles • Valentine’s Day: Use heart-shaped Reese’s and pink decorative elements • Easter celebration: Incorporate pastel colors and Easter candy pieces

Moreover, seasonal packaging makes these bars perfect for gift-giving. Therefore, consider festive containers and ribbons for holiday presentations.

Troubleshooting Common Cheesecake Bar Problems

Even experienced bakers sometimes encounter challenges with cheesecake bars. However, most issues have straightforward solutions that restore perfect results.

Preventing Cracked Surfaces

Surface cracks affect visual appeal but don’t impact taste. Additionally, understanding crack causes helps prevent them in future baking attempts.

Avoid cracking with these techniques:

• Don’t overbeat: Excess air incorporation leads to rising and falling that causes cracks • Proper baking time: Overbaking creates stress that results in surface cracking • Gradual cooling: Rapid temperature changes stress the cheesecake structure • Adequate moisture: Dry oven conditions can cause surface cracking

Moreover, if cracks do appear, they’re easily hidden with toppings or decorative elements. Therefore, don’t worry if minor cracks develop during baking or cooling.

Solving Cutting and Serving Issues

Clean, professional-looking cuts require proper technique and tools. Furthermore, these methods ensure neat presentation for serving.

Achieve perfect cuts:

• Proper chilling: Fully chilled bars cut much more cleanly than warm ones • Sharp, clean knife: Wipe blade between cuts to prevent dragging and tearing • Warm knife slightly: Run under warm water and dry for easier cutting • Gentle pressure: Let the knife do the work rather than forcing cuts

Additionally, dental floss works excellently for cutting cheesecake cleanly. Moreover, unflavored floss slides through without dragging or tearing the surface.

Nutritional Information and Serving Guidelines

Understanding the nutritional content helps you enjoy Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars as part of a balanced approach to treats. Additionally, proper serving sizes maximize enjoyment while managing portions.

Nutritional Breakdown Per Serving

Each bar contains approximately 350 calories when cut into 24 pieces. Moreover, the rich ingredients provide various nutrients alongside the indulgent experience.

Nutritional highlights include:

• Protein from dairy and nuts: Cream cheese and peanut butter contribute muscle-supporting protein • Calcium from cream cheese: Supports bone health and muscle function • Healthy fats from nuts: Peanuts provide beneficial fats and vitamin E • Energy from carbohydrates: Provides quick energy for active lifestyles

Furthermore, the high protein and fat content provides lasting satisfaction. Therefore, smaller portions often satisfy sweet cravings more effectively than larger servings of lighter desserts.

Smart Serving Strategies

Maximize enjoyment while managing portion sizes with these thoughtful approaches. Additionally, proper presentation enhances the overall dessert experience significantly.

Optimize serving experience:

• Cut into 24 pieces: Smaller portions allow people to enjoy without overindulging • Serve chilled: Cold bars have the best texture and flavor intensity • Accompany with milk: Cold milk balances the rich, sweet flavors perfectly • Offer variety: Serve alongside lighter options for different preferences

Moreover, garnishing with fresh berries provides color contrast and palate cleansing. Therefore, consider strawberries or raspberries as attractive accompaniments.

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips for Cheesecake Bars

Proper storage maintains quality and actually improves flavor development over time. Additionally, smart planning makes these bars perfect for entertaining and special occasions.

Optimal Storage Methods

Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars store beautifully when handled correctly. Furthermore, proper storage techniques extend freshness and maintain optimal texture.

Follow these storage guidelines:

• Refrigerate covered: Use plastic wrap or airtight container to prevent drying • Consume within one week: Peak quality lasts up to seven days with proper storage • Freeze for longer storage: Wrap individual pieces and freeze up to three months • Thaw gradually: Move from freezer to refrigerator several hours before serving

Additionally, the candy pieces maintain their texture well during storage. Moreover, flavors actually meld and improve during the first 24-48 hours of refrigeration.

Make-Ahead Success Strategies

Planning ahead makes entertaining stress-free and often improves final results. Furthermore, these bars actually benefit from advance preparation and extended chilling.

Maximize make-ahead benefits:

• Bake 1-2 days ahead: Flavors develop and improve during extended chilling • Cut before storing: Pre-cut pieces are ready for immediate serving • Individual wrapping: Wrap pieces separately for grab-and-go convenience • Freeze components: Make crust ahead and freeze, then add filling later

Moreover, having dessert completely finished before events reduces last-minute stress. Therefore, plan your timeline to complete everything at least one day early.

FAQs About Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars

Can I use different candy bars in these cheesecake bars?

Absolutely! This recipe works beautifully with various candy bar combinations. Additionally, try Snickers and Twix for caramel lovers, or Kit-Kat and Crunch bars for different textures. Moreover, seasonal candy variations work perfectly for holiday themes. However, maintain the same total amount of candy to preserve the proper filling consistency.

How do I prevent the candy pieces from sinking to the bottom?

Toss candy pieces lightly in flour before folding into the filling. Additionally, ensure your filling is thick enough to support the candy pieces properly. Moreover, don’t overmix after adding candy, as this can cause pieces to break down. Furthermore, slightly underbaking helps maintain structure while the bars finish setting during cooling.

Can I make these bars without eggs?

Yes, though the texture will be slightly different. Additionally, you can substitute each egg with 1/4 cup applesauce or commercial egg replacer. Moreover, the bars will be softer and less structured but still delicious. Furthermore, ensure extra chilling time to help them set properly without the binding power of eggs.

Why are my cheesecake bars too soft to cut cleanly?

This usually indicates insufficient chilling time or underbaking. Additionally, ensure you’ve refrigerated the bars for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight. Moreover, the center should be completely set before removing from the oven. Furthermore, using a very sharp knife and wiping between cuts helps achieve clean slices.

Can I make Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars dairy-free?

Yes, with some substitutions! Additionally, use dairy-free cream cheese alternatives and plant-based butter for the crust. Moreover, check that your chosen candy bars are dairy-free or substitute with dairy-free alternatives. Furthermore, the texture may be slightly different, but the flavor will still be delicious.

How far ahead can I make these cheesecake bars?

These bars actually improve when made 1-2 days ahead. Additionally, they store well in the refrigerator for up to one week. Moreover, you can freeze them for up to three months with proper wrapping. Furthermore, the flavors meld together beautifully during extended storage, making advance preparation ideal.

Serving Suggestions and Presentation Ideas

Transform your Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars into stunning dessert presentations with these creative approaches. Additionally, thoughtful garnishing and plating elevate the entire dessert experience.

Professional Presentation Techniques

Simple techniques create dramatic visual impact without requiring advanced decorating skills. Furthermore, professional presentation makes any dessert more appealing and memorable.

Enhance visual appeal:

• Dust with powdered sugar: Light dusting adds elegant finishing touch • Drizzle with chocolate: Decorative chocolate drizzles create restaurant-quality appearance • Garnish with candy pieces: Reserve extra crushed candy for attractive topping • Fresh fruit contrast: Strawberries or raspberries provide beautiful color contrast • Whipped cream dollops: Small cream rosettes add elegance and richness balance

Moreover, chilling plates beforehand prevents condensation that can make presentations look messy. Therefore, place serving plates in the refrigerator 30 minutes before plating.

Party and Event Serving Ideas

These bars work perfectly for various occasions and crowd sizes. Additionally, smart serving strategies make them ideal for entertaining large groups.

Perfect for these occasions:

• Birthday parties: The candy bar theme appeals to all ages • Holiday gatherings: Easy to make ahead for stress-free entertaining • Office parties: Pre-cut bars are perfect for workplace celebrations • Bake sale fundraisers: High-profit margin and guaranteed to sell quickly • Potluck dinners: Travels well and always impresses other guests

Furthermore, consider creating a dessert station with various toppings and sauces. Therefore, guests can customize their bars with additional elements they enjoy.

The Science Behind Perfect Cheesecake Bars

Understanding the science helps you achieve consistent results every time. Additionally, knowledge of ingredient interactions helps troubleshoot problems when they occur.

How Ingredients Work Together

Each ingredient serves specific functions in creating the perfect texture and flavor. Moreover, understanding these roles helps you make successful substitutions when needed.

Ingredient science breakdown:

• Cream cheese: Provides structure, richness, and tangy flavor that balances sweetness • Eggs: Act as binders and create smooth, custard-like texture when baked • Sugar: Sweetens and helps create tender texture through moisture retention • Butter: Adds richness and helps create cohesive crust structure

Additionally, proper ratios ensure the filling sets correctly without being too dense. Furthermore, temperature control affects how these ingredients interact during baking.

Texture Development Secrets

Perfect texture results from careful attention to mixing methods and baking technique. Moreover, understanding texture development helps you achieve professional results.

Achieve optimal texture:

• Proper mixing: Prevents air incorporation that causes density issues • Temperature control: Ensures even cooking throughout the bars • Adequate baking: Sets structure without creating dryness • Proper cooling: Allows texture to develop fully before cutting

Furthermore, the candy pieces add textural interest without compromising the base structure. Therefore, proper incorporation techniques maintain both elements successfully.

Conclusion

Reese’s Butterfinger Cheesecake Bars represent the perfect fusion of beloved candy flavors with classic cheesecake elegance. Moreover, they prove that sometimes combining favorite treats creates something even more spectacular than the individual components. Additionally, the bar format makes them practical for entertaining while maintaining the luxurious appeal of traditional cheesecake.

These incredible bars offer the best of both worlds – familiar candy flavors that everyone loves combined with sophisticated cheesecake texture and presentation. Furthermore, the make-ahead nature eliminates stress when entertaining, while the impressive appearance suggests much more effort than actually required. Therefore, they’re perfect for both casual family treats and special occasion desserts.

Print